BarkBox vs. Bullymake vs. KONG Box: Which Dog Subscription Box is Best for You?
Dog toy subscription boxes are a fantastic way to keep your pup entertained with a regular delivery of new toys and treats. But with so many options on the market, how do you choose the right one? Three of the biggest names in the game are BarkBox, Bullymake, and KONG Box (now KONG Club), and each one caters to a very different type of dog.
Let's unbox the details and help you decide which subscription is the perfect fit for your furry friend.
The Showdown: BarkBox vs. Bullymake vs. KONG Box
Choosing the right box comes down to understanding your dog's chew style and your personal priorities.
| Subscription Box | Best For... | What's Inside? | Key Feature |
| BarkBox | The Playful Pup & Themed Fun | 2 unique toys, 2 bags of treats, 1 chew. |
Creative, fun monthly themes and unique toy designs. Offers a Super Chewer option for tougher dogs.
|
| Bullymake Box | The Power Chewer | 2-3 ultra-durable toys and 3 bags of treats (or an all-toy option). | Unmatched durability. Toys are made from tough nylon, rubber, and ballistic materials. Comes with a 14-day destruction-proof guarantee. |
| KONG Box | The Enrichment Seeker | 1 KONG rubber toy, 1 other toy, 3 KONG treats, and recipe/tip cards. | Focuses on behavioral solutions (anxiety, boredom) and enrichment. Leverages the trusted KONG brandquality. |
A Deeper Look at Each Box
- BarkBox: If you love adorable, themed photoshoots and your dog is an average chewer, the standard BarkBox is a winner. The toys are creative, the themes are hilarious, and the treats are all-natural. If your dog has a bit more bite, the Super Chewer box swaps the plushies for tougher rubber and nylon toys, making it a versatile choice for many households.
- Bullymake Box: This is the undisputed champion for dogs that treat every toy like a challenge to be conquered. Bullymake is built from the ground up for "destroyers." They don't include plush toys in their boxes, focusing solely on materials that can withstand serious chewing. If you're tired of throwing away toy remnants after five minutes, Bullymake is your answer.
- KONG Box (KONG Club): More than just a box of toys, KONG Club positions itself as a behavioral support system. Boxes are tailored to help with issues like crate training, separation anxiety, or boredom. It’s perfect for owners who want to use toys as tools for training and mental stimulation, centered around the classic, stuffable KONG toy.
The Verdict
- For variety and fun, choose BarkBox.
- For extreme durability, choose Bullymake.
- For enrichment and training, choose KONG Box.
No matter which you pick, a subscription box is a wonderful way to discover new favorites and keep your dog's tail wagging month after month.